2002
1st Team - Mike Morgan, Ryan Daniels, Amir Toft
2nd Team - Jaime Vaca, Lance Fair, Joe White, Bill Whalen
2003
1st Team - Steve Stoll, Joe White, Lance Fair
2nd Team - Rubin Avila, Mike Morgan, Mark Englert
Conference Player of the Year - Steve Stoll
2004
1st Team - Mike Morgan, Bill Whalen
2nd Team - Bobby Healy, Scott Kerber
2005
1st Team - Dan Krahl, Ray Jilek, Tom Kane
2nd Team - Bobby Healy, John Powell, Joe Muenzer
2006
1st Team - Dan Krahl, John Powell, Matt Englert
2nd Team - Tom Kane, Alex Gardunio
Conference Player of the Year - Matt Englert
2007
1st Team - John Powell, Ed White, Kevin Sherbin
2nd Team - Matt O'Connor, Greg Toth
Conference Player of the Year - John Powell
2008 (1st Year in Independent School League Conference)
All Conference - Ted Huntington, Bryce Machain, Matt O'Connor, Greg Toth
2009
All Conference - Ted Huntington, Matt O'Connor, Andrew McDonough, Dan Burke, Sam Carter
Conference Player of the Year - Matt O'Connor
2010
All Conference - Ted Huntington, Larry Bilello, Kyle Antene
Conference Player of the Year - Ted Huntington
2011
All Conference - David Nuccio, Peter Kane, Will Strenk
2012
All Conference - Liam Brannon, Conor Doyle, Peter Kane
2013
All Conference - Mike Gigante, Tom Kahle, Sean Gallagher
2014
All Conference - Patrick Hunt, Tom Kahle, Mike McCarthy
2015
All-Conference - Patrick Hunt, Tom Kahle
2016
All-Conference- Patrick Hunt, Mike McCarthy, Joe Skokna
Co-Conference Player of the Year - Patrick Hunt
2017
All-Conference- Thomas Bennett, Matt Kelly, Billy Samano
2018
All-Conference - Thomas Bennett, Billy Samano